Forest Avenue Bagels

I have NEVER seen bagels so big and Fluffy. I was in Staten Island to go to Cherubini. On the way back out, I decided to stop and get a few bagels to commemorate my visit to S.I. and my leaving NY. I'm a Queens baby so we have bagels but these were BAGELS!! I literally cleaned them out. The you first gentleman than was bagging my bagels gave me. a purpose to smile that day. The older gentleman was so nice, so respectful. And for less than $15 I walked out with over 15 bagels of a great variety. *I took all the pumpernickel and wheat first*. I was able to share bagels with 5 people. I ate my straight out the bag! The smell was so enticing.. I had to double bag them to get out the store. Moist, chewy, delightful interior. Freshly baked, nicely cracking exterior. I needed nothing; no toaster, no butter, no eggs. Nothing!! Had I not eaten it so fast, I might eat been able to catch a photo. Whenever I return to S.I. in the future, this will be my go to place.

My favorite fresh bagels when I get back to the Island! Pack em up and freezer them for SI bagels anytime I need them :-) moved to PA so there is absolutely nothing like these here 🤗😊👍

One of the best bacon egg and cheese on a bagel in Staten Island. The bagels are always Fresh out the oven doesn't matter the time of day. Really nice workers as well. The bagels could use a bit more density though.