Benchwarmers

It was a cloudy and warm Sunday morning. We were in the mood for a family breakfast, so decided to come to this Popular Raleigh staple. Upon arrival we were greeted with a huge line of 20+ families. So we decided to just place an order on our phone for pickup. Said 20 min it would be ready, but took closer to 40. Not complaining as the place was slammed so reasonable to wait. The food itself is very good, but the amount of praise this place gets, not “that” good. But definitely a 4 out of 5. The LOX on an everything bagel is the route I went and glad I did because it was delicious. They also have great coffee options, the nitro cold brew and cappuccino is what we went with and both great.

I LOVE bagels! This was my first time at a designated bagel shop and I was so excited! The woman who took my order was so kind and patient and suggested the avocado bagel and it was so amazing!

Benchwarmers is arguably better than many New York bagel shops. I’d say it’s the bagels but reality is that it’s the service. They care. They know what they are doing and know how to satisfy people from far and wide. I’ve been meeting with my mentor of 3 years there every Wednesday morning and it’s a truly sacred place for us. The bagels are amazing and the community there is unlike any other in Raleigh. They are able to handle massive lines and still deliver with authenticity. Love this place so much and thankful for it!

Benchwarmers Bagels, located in the heart of Raleigh, NC, is an absolute standout. It is a favorite among both locals and visitors. In fact, we take all of our out-of-town guests here! Their impeccable service (especially the management), delectable bagels with a range of creative spreads, and the vibrant atmosphere within a food hall create an extraordinary laid-back dining experience. The warm and welcoming staff, coupled with the sheer quality and variety of their bagels, make each visit an unforgettable meal. Benchwarmers Bagels is a true gem in Raleigh, where every bite is a taste of perfection, and the atmosphere is filled with a communal, energetic vibe. Don't miss the chance to indulge in their bagels and coffee and enjoy a memorable dining experience.

We've been going to Benchwarmer's since they opened up several years ago, and it is one of our favorite spots in Raleigh! I always recommend getting one of their amazing and fun bagel sandwiches as opposed to just a bagel with cream cheese (even though these are still great; try the maitre d'hotel cream cheese!). Look for their weekend specials as they are usually interesting and delicious. My favorite constant sandwhich on their menu is the #5 with smoked fish spread, pickled veggies, potatoe chips, and roe on a za'atar and sea salt bagel. The za'atar is hands down their best bagel and it is criminally underrated! Their coffee/espresso is great and their rotating 5th Quarter Cappuccino is my go-to. If you get there early enough, definitely get a Cardamom Bun or two; they are sooo good. A couple of disclaimers: These are not New York style bagels so don't expect that, but they are still delicious. There is almost always a line to order on weekend mornings, so make sure you plan accordingly (took about 25 minutes to order and receive my bagels around 11:30am on a Sat). They are definitely worth the wait! They do sicilian style pizza on Thurs-Sat night and they are super good. It may seem expensive, but it ends up being a lot more pizza than you'd think. Again, try the weekend special!