Quickly becoming one of my favorite pizzas in Milwaukee! We ordered delivery cause Monday had a 16” special and we just moved in down the street and now we know Monday nights will be pizza nights! The pepperoni was great, the sausage was incredible, but best of all is the crust and sauce! I love this thicker (but not thick) style of crust and the seasoning on it is incredible. And the sauce is just a touch sweet to offset it
Drove by this place millions of times but never stopped I did stop a couple months ago and I'm glad I did! I usually go on Thursdays because Maria is working and I love the way she makes my pizza! Everybody is friendly there and I never had a complaint going there about maybe eight times now. I hope I never get disappointed because then I'll have to look for a new pizza place and it's hard these days!
My favorite pizza place in Bay View--maybe the entire city--maybe ever.
They are owned and operated by a family of wise guys who hand-make traditional pizza that is sometimes the highlight of my day. Fight with the wife? Bad day at work? Existential crisis of purpose? Call Pietro. You'll get a great pizza and possibly even some life advice from actual Italians if you pick it up.
Quick tip--specify you want the pizza thin crust. It's not listed on the menu, but it makes for a great ratio of cheese and toppings to crust.
Go to place for pizza in Bay View, it is always delicious! Pietro himself made us these cannoli and they were so good! Highly recommended!
Cool guy, Pietro. He speaks a lot of languages, likes knowing where people come from. Great pizza and canolis!
Great place. Only to go orders/ delivery. Had the lasagna. Good flavor and the price was great
Fantastic pizza, good quality and great taste. Sauce is a little sweet and they put a nice variety of seasoning and herbs in the crust and on top. 10/10 will order again.
Pietros is my favorite pizza in Milwaukee. Their crust is great, their sauce is great, they have artichoke as a topping. Not many places offer this. Their thin crust is very good but my favorite is their “double thick” which is like virgin crust or hand tossed in my opinion. The only gripe I have is they make mistakes with the crust, often. I may be the only one in Milwaukee who likes the thick crust. The pizza Is never bad but it’s not always exactly what I order. Do I recommend you try their pizza anyway? Absolutely!
Update: ordered pizza again tonight-extra thick, sausage mushrooms artichoke on the whole pizza. Picked it up and got exactly what I ordered. I love their pizza! Great crust, great sauce, great toppings!
Ordered from Uber eats and it’s was great! I asked for thin and well done and it was perfection! One of the best pizzas I’ve found in Milwaukee since moving from chicago a year ago!
They haven’t up dated their website so their prices are way higher than it says, however comparable to other places. Food is good and people are very nice
Prenota un tavolo
Ordina online
Trova il miglior ristorante di Milwaukee
Si è verificato un errore! Riprova tra qualche minuto