New York Pasta Garden is an outstanding Italian restaurant that truly impressed us. Our server, Fletcher, was not only awesome but also incredibly kind; he provided exceptional service with generous portions for each dish. We indulged in Artichoke fried, Alfredo Pasta with Vegetables, Garden Salad, and a delightful complementary Garlic bread that left our taste buds thoroughly satisfied. The prices were reasonable, and the restaurant's ambiance had an inviting antique charm that exceeded our expectations.
However, what truly stood out was the delectable taste of the food and the impeccable service provided by Fletcher. He expertly recommended dishes tailored to our preferences and was exceptionally friendly throughout our dining experience.
The only downsides were the absence of free Wi-Fi and the challenge of finding a free parking spot. We opted for paid street-side parking, which cost $5 per hour.
This place is a hidden gem. My husband and l stayed in Key West for 5 days, we ate here twice!!! The outside is gorgeous, the staff and owner is very friendly. The food is OUT OF THIS WORLD!! They have AMAZING gluten free pasta which is a huge plus. This is the place to come! Will definitely return. Everything 10/10 ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
My husband and I went there for dinner for our honeymoon weekend. Fletcher is hands down amazing and so up lifting. Food was amazing and hot!!! Bread is out of this world! I had the shrimp Alfredo which was exactly what I wanted and my husband had the shrimp and scallop dish which he also loved. Fletcher made our night on top of the amazing food. We will be back for sure when we go back in the future not just for the food but for Fletcher!!
Our food was fantastic. I had the steak salad and my husband had the egg plant parm.
The food was amazing, the only thing better than it was the service by the incredible nice staff!
We'd give it a 10 star rating if we could! The price was more than okay, really. The homemade dressing and the parmesan breadrolls were DELICIOUS!
Thank you for the comfortable atmosphere and the generous amounts of wine
Anytime again!
My wife and I had dinner last night. It was raining so we initially sat inside. While we were waiting a group of young ladies decided to brave the weather and sat outside. That was just the push we needed so we asked to be seated outside as well. The tables had large umbrellas so we we able to have our dinner without getting wet. My wife had the lasagna and I had the Carbonara. Both were very good. I had the Onion Soup as well. We were cautioned that all of the food was hot. They were right. I don't think I was ever served food as hot. Fletcher and Donna were entertaining as well as efficient. Had a great time.
We just happened to stumble upon the restaurant while we were walking down duval street. The server was awesome ( never got his name). We were just about to order when the power went out. He offered us a free beer or glass of wine while we waited to see if the power would come back on soon. It started to rain so they moved everyone inside. About 15 minutes later the power came. He brought us a free appetizer as a thank you for staying around while the power was off. He had a great personality. We ordered and the food was great. I would definitely recommend. Overall great experience.
A small establishment that has quality food for a great price. At the time of writing you could get a nice glass of wine for around 11 and a bottle of beer for around 5.50. the sandwiches were tasty and filling, the fries are great with their dressing. The dressing was so good, I wish they'd sell it !
My husband and I were visiting Key West with friends and returned again after eating at NY Pasta Garden the first time in 2021. The food was great and the service was amazing. Donna took excellent care of us. Loved the small bite garlic bread, onion soup, fettuccine, chicken Marsala, and cheesecake dessert. Everything was divine. We will definitely be back.
Just amazing!
We.stopped in for a late dinner. (about 8pm) Atmosphere was charming, we sat outside under the lights, there was a wonderful breeze blowing through the Duval Square Mall, so it was very comfortable to sit outside.
Ordered a house chardonnay and it wIas huge! Way more than even 9 oz. There were two of us, we shared an antipasto. No am not a fan of cured meat, so photo represents how I modified the item. We.also shared an entree, Pasta Bella Mare. Check out the online menu for details. Entree was superb, just enough for the two of us. We finished with a slice of lemoncello cake, delicious!
Our waitress was attentive, knowledgeable and delightful! A Czech sweetheart at home in an Italian eatery.
Only disappointment was the little garlic bread bites were a little hard and when we asked for a decaf coffee, we were told there was none. I'm their defense, it was close to closing and they must have had to brew an entire pot.
We will definitely eat there again, worth every penny!
Prenota un tavolo
Ordina online
Trova il miglior ristorante di Key West
Si è verificato un errore! Riprova tra qualche minuto