Delicious! My husband and I are super picky about our pizza and are always trying new places around Indy. We saw Pietro's open up down the street and decided to give it a whirl. We've now found our go-to pizzeria. The quantity and quality of ingredients is fantastic. Very fresh with lots of cheesy goodness :-P. If you're on the fence about trying a new place, go for it! You won't regret it!
Pietro's pizza is one of the best yet unknown pizza places in Indy. They use quality ingredients and don't skip on the helpings. Their stuffed pizzas are my favorite, hands down. Definitely would suggest it to friends!
Excellent Pizza. Quality meat, cheese and bread. A little pricey but I'm willing to pay for the quality. I wouldn't call it gourmet but its definitely not "fast food." It was wonderfully simple. I ordered a thin crust with pepperoni and extra cheese. The crust was fresh and buttery and I didn't need the extra cheese! I'm a "cheese head" but the extra cheese was almost too much cheese--if that's possible. Pizza was cooked to perfection. Plenty of fresh marinara and gooey cheese. Real cheese. I didn't try the salads but they appeared to be fresh. This is my new favorite spot. Give it a whirl!
Delivery took well over an hour to get to my apartment which is on 96th street. Less than 3 miles away! Also they didn't give me any salad dressing for the salad I ordered. I had never ordered from here before and I will be trying some place else next time. This way I could get what I pay for at least. It was my first try at a pizza place since I moved to Indiana. 😔
The calzone was pretty good.
*Update * they do care and tried to make it right. I appreciate the thought and effort. I gave this place another shot. It was very good and the staff are really polite. Thanks again for reaching out.
Being from Chicagoland, I always complained about pizza when I moved to Indy, that changed when I found Pietro's. Their stuffed pizza is incredible, best pizza in Indy. Plus, you can get some cannolis for dessert.
The food was delicious. The service was excellent. When you want food that tastes homemade from authentic Italian recipes, Pietro's is the place to go. The best Pizza in Indianapolis!!!!
Best Pizza on North side by far. Been to them all! Fresh ingredients, garlic butter hand brushed on each crust. Pietro is truly an artist!
Pietro's is our absolute favorite pizza place. Their thick crust pizza is to die for. Such a good hole-in-the-wall pizzeria! AMAZING!
Thank you for opening in the Indy area! I've been searching for this kind of pizza since I moved here 15 years ago.
I LOVE this pizza! Great local find!
Prenota un tavolo
Ordina online
Trova il miglior ristorante di Indianapolis
Si è verificato un errore! Riprova tra qualche minuto