I came here with my friends for the first time after a concert, and this place was amazing!!! Despite there being a long line for the pizza, the line moved quickly, and the service was fantastic. Every slice of pizza was fresh and delicious, and the giant breadsticks were SO good! We are definitely stopping by again next time we're in the area.
Stopped by for a late lunch. I made it in time for the lunch special - what a deal! Slice, side, and a drink for $9. The pizza was hot, the crust was perfect. Delicious! Great service! The music was just a little loud, I was there alone but it may have been difficult to have a conversation if someone was with me. Otherwise it was a great experience!
We were in town from Ottawa Canada for the NHRA US Nationals and wanted good pizza so decided to try out Goodfellas... we were not disappointed.... The guys at the front were great, they make a great pie... went on a monday and it was half price pizza. While waiting for the pizza went into the Whiskey Louge, had a few drinks, bartender was great... what a bartender should be... don't have a lot of places like this anymore... If I lived in Indy, it would be my goto place.
Visited this place on a Saturday night, it was packed but my friend and I did manage to get a seat at the bar behind the main pizza counter in front. We ordered a pizza and two of the large breadsticks. The pizza did take about 45-60min to come out, probably due to how busy they were.
While we waited we tried a few cocktails. I had the Bonnie martini. Would recommend it.
The place is pretty good, they have a good selection of specialty pizzas. Also, have decent sides, that go well with the pizza. We've tried almost every pizza there and can't complain. Highly recommend the Buffalo chicken cheese bread! 👌 The desserts are also pretty good too.
Always order pickup because the place is PACKED and steadily busy. 4 stars due to waiting to order and having to wait to grab your pickup order. They should definitely have a better system for pickups. You go in for a pickup order and have to wait in line or cut in front of everyone to still stand and wait till they notice you to get your name for the order. The place is always extremely loud due to so many people being there and the music. If they had a two-cash register system it would run so much smoother.
All in all still has great food and they are open late. Would definitely recommend this place for pizzas! 🍕
It was the 3rd best slice of pizza I've ever had. And they have an awesome speak easy in the back.
Pizza was amazingly delicious! Portions were great and prices were reasonable! Staff was nice and informative. Should have gotten more than two slices.
The main area looks like any other college pizza by the slice place, but to the back left of the main restaurant is a hidden bar. GREAT bar with Excellent Bourbon and Whisky selection. You can bring your pizza and super long breadsticks to the bar and have a great time.
Great experience, very friendly & helpful staff. Loved it
Goodfellas is delicious and well worth the wait on weekends, especially if you’ve been out to the bars. I once legitimately cried because I was drunk and we weren’t going to stop there on the way home and it was all I wanted in that moment. Highly recommend the pepperoni and jalapeño, but the case rotates and all of it is good. Cool to watch them making the pizzas too, they spin the dough and everything.
Prenota un tavolo
Ordina online
Trova il miglior ristorante di Indianapolis
Si è verificato un errore! Riprova tra qualche minuto