Horse Thief Hollow

My wife and I have been going here for a few years now, as good friends just live down the street from it, but recently we've become more frequent flyers and have introduced this amazing place to a bunch of our friends and family. We've visited the last three weekends: once with another couple, then with my wife's parents, and finally with a party of 14 last night. Each time we ordered food, had their wonderful craft beer, and had their delightful cocktails. For every single group, everyone was blown away on all levels. The ambiance is phenomenal with innovative décor and local art. The high wood ceiling is beautiful and every way you turn, there is something both beautiful and interesting to look at. Always bustling, but incredibly diverse in age and race. SO refreshing considering there are way too many breweries that are mono-cultural. The beer is some of the best we've ever had. Innovative, tasty, and easily the best version of whatever style it's in. From IPA's and DIPA's to NEIPA's, from porters to stouts to imperial stouts, from goses to sours, and even guest ales like meads from Wild Blossom and great craft beer from other local places, they do things right. Having a full bar and expert mixologists helps a ton for our friends that like variety. Best Manhattans and Old Fashioned our parties have ever had (and they've sampled a lot from Chicagoand). The food. OMG THE FOOD!!! Southwest Eggrolls that explode in your mouth, Gumbo that is just the right amount of spicy and flavorful, burgers and pastrami sandwiches that will keep you coming back, sweet potato fries not done better than anywhere else except for the deep south, crazy good salads, and great dessert choices. Accommodating to kids as well (I have a few elementary and middle school students where this is their favorite place to go). And the STAFF! What beautiful people that hustle, accommodate, and show such grace and patience they deserve medals every night! Even with our party of 14 last night, everyone was served well and on time, no matter how crazy our tastes got. They are quite easily the best in the business. Parking is plentiful and free to boot! I could not make a higher recommendation for this beautiful place nestled in the Beverly neighborhood!

Great tasting food, excellent service! Had the Dunkel stein of the house brewed beer & the Sicilianaire with a side salad. The other party had the pulled pork sandwich. & the cheese pierogi was amazing! (Didn't get a pic of that, it disappeared so fast)

We recently had our company Christmas party at Horse Thief, as we have had in the past 3 years, the food and service was outstanding! The Green Beret brew was fabulous as well as the Cobb Salad. Beautifully decorated and loved the atmosphere! Check it out for the New Year!

Nice, friendly, inviting staff and atmosphere. This was my first visit, but not my last. I took my mother here for lunch today. The mural on the exterior wall of the parking lot, as well as the painting on the asphalt was very impressive! My mother had the Grass-fed burger and I had the Turkey burger. Both burgers were delicious--we ate it all. I recommend trying their cocktail called "The Ambassador". It's a refreshing drink with gin, lemon, honey, and all-spice.

Stopped in for some drinks & an appetizer. Absolutely loved the Cajun Crab Rangoons. They were delicious! Drinks were really good as well. Our server was great and loved the atmosphere.

I’ve been to this place many times and I love it. Went on a Saturday for dinner. I had the venison burger and Mac & cheese. We got our order pretty fast. I recommend ‘kitchen sink’. The dinning area is pretty big and is kid friendly. I noticed a new patio on the side where the parking lot used to be. Looked pretty nice but it was closed due to rain.